Aviation Accident Summaries

Aviation Accident Summary FTW98LA243

WICHITA, KS, USA

Aircraft #1

N619AU

Boeing 757-2B7

Analysis

During cruise at 39,000 feet, the scheduled domestic passenger flight encountered severe turbulence after inadvertently penetrating a rapidly developing convective cell (thunderstorm). One flight attendant was seriously injured, and three flight attendants and three passengers sustained minor injuries. There was no damage to the Boeing 757 airplane. When the turbulence encounter occurred, the flight was deviating around a large area of thunderstorms located about 40 nautical miles right of the airplane's flight path. The cell that the airplane penetrated was very small in comparison to the area of storms the flightcrew was trying to avoid. The seat belt sign was illuminated prior to the turbulence encounter. All of the injured flight attendants were attempting to stow food service items when the airplane encountered the sudden 'violent jolt that slammed [them] against the ceiling.' Following the turbulence encounter, the flight diverted to a nearby airport and landed without further incident.

Factual Information

On May 24, 1998, at 1931 central daylight time (CDT), US Airways flight 007, a Boeing 757-2B7, N619AU, encountered severe turbulence during cruise flight at 39,000 feet mean sea level (msl) approximately 75 nautical miles (NM) southeast of Wichita, Kansas. There were 120 passengers, 2 flightcrew members, and 6 flight attendants aboard the airplane. One flight attendant was seriously injured, and three flight attendants and three passengers sustained minor injuries. There was no damage to the airplane. The regularly scheduled passenger flight was operating under 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 121. Flight 007 departed from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, at 1810 eastern daylight time and was en route to Los Angeles, California. An instrument flight rules (IFR) flight plan had been filed; however, according to the flightcrew, the airplane was operating in visual meteorological conditions at the time of the accident. Following the turbulence encounter, the flight diverted to Will Rogers World Airport in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, and landed without further incident at 2004 CDT. According to the captain, as the flight approached the Wichita area, he "altered [the] flight path to the left to avoid weather observed on [the airplane's] weather radar and reported by other aircraft." The captain reported that the "nearest radar returns were 40 - 50 NM off to our right." He further reported that he turned on the seat belt sign and made an announcement to the passengers when the flight encountered "light chop approximately eight minutes prior to the severe turbulence encounter." Following the turbulence encounter, the lead flight attendant advised the captain that two of the flight attendants were injured, and he elected to divert to Oklahoma City for medical assistance. The first officer's recollection of the event agreed with the captain's. According to the first officer, "the nearest radar returns were well off to our right, approximately 60 NM." The seriously injured flight attendant reported that the seat belt sign was on and an announcement to the passengers had been made. It "started getting turbulent," and she entered the rear galley to assist another flight attendant in closing and latching compartments. She stated that, "the next thing I knew was my head hit the ceiling and then I was slammed onto the floor." According to the flight attendant, in addition to muscle strains and bruises, she sustained "4 hairline fractures in the L2 & L4 vertebrae and the knobs had been broken off." Of the three flight attendants who received minor injuries, one was in the rear galley with the seriously injured flight attendant, another was assisting the lead flight attendant in stowing a cart at the rear of the first class cabin, and the third was in the first class galley. All three reported that following "some mild turbulence," there was a sudden "violent jolt that slammed [them] against the ceiling of the aircraft." According to information provided by the FAA's Kansas City Air Route Traffic Control Center, at 1926, flight 007 requested a deviation of 10 degrees left of course for about 100 miles. The air traffic controller working the flight approved this request. At 1932, flight 007 advised the controller that the flight needed to deviate more to the left, about 20 degrees. Flight 007 further advised the controller that the flight had encountered occasional severe turbulence about 10 miles ago. At 1940, flight 007 advised the controller that the severe turbulence had injured two flight attendants and requested to proceed direct to Oklahoma City. Review of flight data recorder information indicated that the turbulence encounter occurred at approximately 1931. Radar data provided by Kansas City Center indicated that at this time, the airplane was located about 37 degrees 00 minutes 29 seconds north latitude and 96 degrees 05 minutes 53 seconds west longitude, at a pressure altitude of 39,000 feet msl (flight level (FL) 390). An NTSB meteorologist reviewed Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES) data. The GOES 9 visible images for 1900 and 1930 showed a large convective cloud area west-northwest of the location of the turbulence encounter (to the right of the flight path). Looping of the visible images indicated that this area was expanding to the east-southeast (towards the flight path). Plotting the radar data provided by Kansas City Center on the 1930 GOES 9 infrared image showed that when the airplane was at locations corresponding to radar return times of 1925:22 to 1934:58, maximum cloud tops were greater than FL 350 but less than FL 390. The NTSB meteorologist also reviewed Doppler weather radar data from the Tulsa, Oklahoma, WSR-88D site (KINX). Cross sections of weather radar reflectivity (in dBZ) along the flight path of flight 007 were constructed for KINX times of 1919:37, 1925:27, and 1931:18. For the area where the turbulence encounter occurred, the cross sections showed weather radar echoes to a height of 13 kilometers (43,000 feet) at 1919:37, to a height near 14 kilometers (46,000 feet) at 1925:27, and to a height near 14 kilometers at 1931:18. The maximum radar reflectivities in the region of the turbulence encounter were 29 dBZ (very weak weather echoes) at 1919:37, 46 dBZ (very strong weather echoes) at 1925:27, and 50 dBZ (intense weather echoes) at 1931:18. Plan view weather radar reflectivity images at several elevation angles for KINX times 1919:37, 1925:27, and 1931:18 were examined. Within about a 10-kilometer (5.4 NM) radius of the turbulence encounter location, the images showed a maximum weather radar echo intensity of 37 dBZ (moderate weather echo) at 1919:37, 46 dBZ (very strong weather echo) at 1925:27, and 55 dBZ (extreme weather echo) at 1931:18. The images also showed a large area of intense weather radar echoes located about 38 nautical miles west (to the right) of the flight path of flight 007. Additionally, the NTSB meteorologist reviewed Convective SIGMET, Center Weather Advisory, and Tornado Watch messages in effect at the time of the event. There were no Convective SIGMETs or Kansas City Center Weather Advisories in effect for the location of the turbulence encounter. Tornado Watch number 409 issued at 1712 was in effect for an area that included the location of the turbulence encounter. In addition to tornadoes, the watch warned of 3-inch hail at the surface and aloft, wind gusts to 70 knots, and maximum cell tops to 55,000 feet msl. For further weather information, see the NTSB Meteorological Factual Report.

Probable Cause and Findings

The severe turbulence encountered as a result of the flightcrew's inadvertent flight into a rapidly developing thunderstorm.

 

Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database

Get all the details on your iPhone or iPad with:

Aviation Accidents App

In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports